Article 358 automatically suspends Article 19 freedoms during National Emergency proclaimed on grounds of war or external aggression, but not during Emergency proclaimed on ground of armed rebellion.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Article 358 nuanced application: (a) Automatic suspension: Article 19 freedoms (speech, assembly, etc.) automatically suspended only when Emergency proclaimed on war/external aggression grounds (not armed rebellion), (b) Rationale: During war/external aggression, national security may require immediate restrictions on freedoms; during armed rebellion (internal threat), freedoms may be restricted via Article 359 order if necessary, (c) Duration: Suspension lasts for Emergency duration; laws made during suspension remain valid even after Article 19 revival, (d) Safeguards: (i) 44th Amendment limited automatic suspension to war/external aggression, (ii) Courts can examine if restrictions proportionate to threat, (iii) Core rights (Articles 20-21) always protected, (e) Balance: Enable crisis response while preventing overreach; differentiated treatment based on threat nature. Illustrates calibrated rights balancing: context-sensitive restrictions within constitutional framework.