GK Question

polity hard fill_blank

The Preamble's sovereignty commitment informs border security: Supreme Court has upheld state's power to regulate borders, citizenship, while requiring procedural safeguards for detainees, reflecting that sovereignty requires ______ security measures respecting human dignity, rule of law.

  1. absolute
  2. calibrated
  3. minimal
  4. delegated

Answer: calibrated

Sovereignty and border security from Preamble: (a) Preamble's sovereignty: Supreme authority in internal, external affairs; exercised through constitutional framework balancing security needs with rights protection, (b) Border security operationalization: (i) Citizenship: Constitution (Articles 5-11), Citizenship Act regulate acquisition, termination of citizenship; balance national identity with humanitarian considerations, (ii) Border management: BSF, coastal security, fencing, surveillance protect territorial integrity while facilitating legitimate cross-border movement, (iii) Detention safeguards: Procedural due process (notice, hearing, legal aid) for detainees, especially vulnerable groups (children, asylum seekers), (c) Calibrated security dimensions: (i) Proportionality: Security measures must be rationally connected to legitimate aim, necessary, balanced against rights impact, (ii) Non-discrimination: Border policies must not discriminate based on religion, ethnicity, nationality without objective justification, (iii) Humanitarian considerations: Asylum, refugee protection, family reunification balanced with security concerns, (d) Applications: (i) CAA-NRC debates: Balance citizenship verification with non-discrimination, humanitarian principles, (ii) Border disputes: Judicial, diplomatic resolution of territorial disputes (e.g., Sir Creek, Kalapani) through constitutional, international law frameworks, (iii) Cross-border cooperation: SAARC, BIMSTEC mechanisms for security, development cooperation with neighbors, (e) Illustrates adaptive sovereignty: Preamble's sovereignty promise operationalized through calibrated border security; balance between territorial integrity, human rights, regional cooperation essential to constitutional democracy in interconnected world.

Topic Preamble - Sovereignty and Border Security
Exam Relevance Preamble sovereignty and border security critical for UPSC Mains and Judiciary exams