GK Question

polity hard true_false

The Preamble's 'Secular' commitment (added by 42nd Amendment) means the Indian state maintains principled distance from all religions, treating all faiths with equal respect, not that the state is atheistic or hostile to religion.

  1. True
  2. False

Answer: True

Secularism in Preamble: (a) Indian secularism: Not Western model of strict separation (state religion-free zone) but principled distance: (i) State neutrality: No official religion, no preference for any faith, (ii) Equal respect: All religions treated with equal dignity, state can intervene to reform religious practices violating Fundamental Rights, (iii) Not atheism: State not hostile to religion; individuals free to practice, propagate faith subject to public order, morality, health, (b) Constitutional operationalization: (i) Articles 25-28: Freedom of religion, subject to public order, morality, health, (ii) Article 15: Prohibition of religious discrimination, (iii) Article 29-30: Minority rights to conserve culture, establish educational institutions, (c) Applications: (i) Religious reform: State can legislate to abolish discriminatory practices (e.g., triple talaq, temple entry restrictions), (ii) Minority protection: State can support minority educational institutions while ensuring secular education, (iii) Public order: State can regulate religious practices threatening public order, health, morality, (d) Judicial interpretation: (i) SR Bommai (1994): Secularism part of basic structure; state action against secularism can justify President's Rule, (ii) Shirur Mutt (1954): Defined 'religion' for constitutional protection, balancing religious freedom with social reform, (e) Illustrates calibrated secularism: Preamble's secular commitment operationalized through constitutional provisions; balance between religious freedom and social reform, individual faith and collective welfare essential to Indian secularism.

Topic Preamble - Secularism and State-Religion Relations
Exam Relevance Preamble secularism critical for UPSC Mains and Judiciary exams