Create a custom practice set
Pick category, difficulty, number of questions, and time limit. Start instantly with your own quiz.
Generate QuizGK Question
In SR Bommai v. Union of India (1994), the Supreme Court distinguished between 'constitutional breakdown' and 'political instability'. Which of the following best describes 'constitutional breakdown' justifying Article 356?
- Change of government through democratic elections
- Genuine inability of State government to function in accordance with Constitution
- Disagreement between State and Union on policy matters
- Electoral defeat of ruling party in State
Answer: Genuine inability of State government to function in accordance with Constitution
Constitutional breakdown vs political instability: (a) SR Bommai distinction: (i) Constitutional breakdown: Genuine inability of State government to function in accordance with Constitution (e.g., loss of majority verified through floor test, breakdown of law and order beyond State control, action against constitutional principles), (ii) Political instability: Change of government through democratic process, policy disagreement, electoral defeat — NOT justification for Article 356, (b) Examples of constitutional breakdown: (i) Loss of majority verified through floor test, (ii) Breakdown of law and order beyond State control, (iii) Action against constitutional principles (secularism, democracy), (c) Examples NOT justifying Article 356: (i) Political instability, change of government through democratic process, (ii) Policy disagreement with Union, (iii) Electoral defeat of ruling party, (d) Applications: (i) Post-1994: Courts more willing to strike down Article 356 proclamations based on political instability, not genuine constitutional breakdown, (ii) Federal balance: Protects State autonomy against arbitrary Centre overreach, (e) Illustrates constitutional federalism: 'Constitutional breakdown' narrowly defined to protect State autonomy; judicial review ensures Article 356 used for genuine crises, not political convenience.