GK Question

polity hard mcq

During a National Emergency under Article 352, the distribution of legislative powers between Union and States is temporarily modified. Which of the following best describes this modification?

  1. State List subjects become exclusively Union subjects permanently
  2. Parliament can legislate on State List subjects, but such laws cease 6 months post-Emergency
  3. State Legislatures lose all legislative powers permanently
  4. Concurrent List subjects become Union-exclusive permanently

Answer: Parliament can legislate on State List subjects, but such laws cease 6 months post-Emergency

Legislative powers during Emergency: (a) Article 250: During Emergency, Parliament can legislate on any matter in State List, (b) Temporal limitation: Laws made under Article 250 cease to operate 6 months after Emergency ceases, except for things done/omitted before expiry, (c) Rationale: Enable unified national response to existential threats while preserving State legislative domain post-crisis, (d) Applications: (i) 1962, 1971 Emergencies: Parliament legislated on defence, security matters affecting States, (ii) Post-Emergency: Laws ceased after 6 months unless re-enacted by Parliament/State Legislatures, (e) Federal balance: Temporary enhancement of Union legislative power for crisis management, reversible post-Emergency to restore federal normalcy, (f) Illustrates adaptive federalism: Enabling coordinated national response to existential threats while preserving State autonomy through time limits, sunset provisions.

Topic Article 352 - Effect on Distribution of Powers
Exam Relevance Legislative powers during Emergency critical for UPSC Mains and Judiciary exams