Create a custom practice set
Pick category, difficulty, number of questions, and time limit. Start instantly with your own quiz.
Generate QuizGK Question
Which statement best captures the role of Finance Commissions in Indian fiscal federalism?
- FCs impose uniform fiscal policies on all States
- FCs mediate fiscal claims between Union and States through technical, independent assessment, promoting cooperative federalism
- FCs eliminate State autonomy in fiscal matters
- FCs focus only on Union finances, not State finances
Answer: FCs mediate fiscal claims between Union and States through technical, independent assessment, promoting cooperative federalism
Finance Commission role in fiscal federalism: (a) Constitutional mandate: Article 280 requires President to constitute FC every 5 years to recommend distribution of tax revenues between Union and States, grants-in-aid principles, (b) Mediation function: (i) Technical assessment: FC uses objective criteria (population, income distance, area, forest cover, demographic performance) to mediate fiscal claims, depoliticizing resource distribution, (ii) Independent arbitration: FC as independent body balances Union fiscal space with State autonomy, needier States with reforming States, (iii) Cooperative federalism: FC recommendations enable cooperative fiscal governance through dialogue, consensus, not coercion, (c) Applications: (i) Vertical devolution: FC recommends share of Union taxes to States (41% by 15th FC), enabling State expenditure autonomy, (ii) Horizontal distribution: FC allocates State shares using criteria balancing equity (needier States) with efficiency (rewarding reforms), (iii) Grants-in-aid: FC recommends grants for local bodies, disaster management, sectoral priorities, complementing devolution, (d) Challenges: (i) Political pressures: FC recommendations may face political resistance if perceived as unfavorable, (ii) Implementation: States, Union must implement FC recommendations in good faith for cooperative federalism to work, (iii) Adaptation: FC must evolve criteria to address contemporary challenges (climate change, digital governance, demographic transition), (e) Illustrates institutionalized fiscal federalism: FC provides regular, technical mediation of Centre-State fiscal claims; independent, criteria-based approach promotes cooperative federalism, depoliticizes resource distribution.