Create a custom practice set
Pick category, difficulty, number of questions, and time limit. Start instantly with your own quiz.
Generate QuizGK Question
Natural justice principles can be excluded by statute, but Indian courts interpret such exclusion clauses narrowly. Which statement correctly reflects judicial approach to statutory exclusion of natural justice?
- Courts always uphold statutory exclusion of natural justice
- Courts presume natural justice applies unless statute expressly and necessarily excludes it, and even then, post-decisional hearing may be required
- Natural justice can never be excluded by statute
- Exclusion applies only to economic regulations, not rights-affecting decisions
Answer: Courts presume natural justice applies unless statute expressly and necessarily excludes it, and even then, post-decisional hearing may be required
Judicial approach to statutory exclusion of natural justice: (a) Presumption in favor of natural justice: Courts presume legislature intended natural justice to apply unless statute expressly excludes it, (b) Narrow interpretation of exclusion: Even if statute excludes natural justice, courts interpret narrowly: (i) Exclusion must be express, clear, unambiguous, (ii) Exclusion must be necessary to achieve statutory purpose (not just convenient), (c) Post-decisional hearing: If pre-decisional hearing excluded for urgency/emergency, courts often require post-decisional hearing to satisfy fairness, (d) Applications: (i) Preventive detention: Initial detention without hearing, but advisory board review within 3 months (Article 22), (ii) Epidemic control: Immediate quarantine, but appeal mechanism, (iii) Financial emergency: Immediate salary reductions, but parliamentary oversight, (e) Rationale: Balance legislative intent (efficiency in emergencies) with constitutional values (fairness, rights protection); courts ensure exclusion not abused to deny fairness. Illustrates constitutional interpretation: statutes read in light of constitutional values; exclusion of fairness narrowly construed.